Spouse vs Non-Spouse Inherited Annuity Rules Under SECURE Act 2.0

A surviving spouse who is the sole beneficiary can usually continue an inherited annuity as their own contract, so no payout and no tax are triggered yet. A non-spouse beneficiary cannot. They must empty the contract on a deadline, generally 10 years for IRA money or 5 years for non-qualified money, unless a life expectancy option applies.

When someone leaves you an annuity, the paperwork treats you one of two ways. Either your name goes on the deed, or your name goes on a guest pass. A spouse gets the deed. The contract can simply change hands and keep running, same insurer, same terms, same tax deferral, as if it had been yours all along. Nobody has to cash anything out. Nothing shows up on a tax return that year.

Everyone else gets the guest pass. You are welcome inside, the money is genuinely yours, but there is a checkout time printed on the pass. The IRS wants the contract emptied on a schedule, and every dollar of growth that comes out is ordinary income to you in the year you take it.

That single fork explains almost every question people have about inherited annuities. It is not about how much you inherited or how close you were to the person. It is about which side of the spouse line you are standing on, and, if you are on the non-spouse side, whether you fall into one of the narrow exceptions Congress carved out. Let us walk the whole fork.

What actually separates a spouse from a non-spouse beneficiary?

The separation is a specific provision in the tax code that lets a surviving spouse step into the owner’s shoes, and gives that right to nobody else by default. For non-qualified annuities (bought with money you already paid tax on), it is Internal Revenue Code section 72(s)(3). For annuities held inside an IRA, it is the spousal rollover and the surviving-spouse rules the IRS describes in Publication 590-B.

There is a second reason the fork matters so much: annuities do not get a step-up in cost basis at death. The gain that built up during the owner’s lifetime is what the tax code calls income in respect of a decedent under IRC section 691, and it stays taxable to whoever receives it. A spouse can postpone that reckoning for decades. A non-spouse mostly cannot.

What can a surviving spouse do that nobody else can?

A surviving spouse can keep the contract alive instead of collecting on it, and that is the whole advantage. Continuation is an election, not an automatic event, and most insurers require the spouse to be the sole primary beneficiary before they will allow it.

• Continue a non-qualified annuity as the new owner under IRC 72(s)(3), with the original purchase date, cost basis, and tax deferral intact.
• Treat an inherited IRA annuity as their own IRA, which resets required distributions to the spouse’s own birth year rather than the deceased owner’s.
• Stay a beneficiary of the IRA instead, which can be the better move when the surviving spouse is under 59 and a half and may need penalty-free access.
• Elect, in an employer plan, to be treated as the deceased participant for required distribution purposes under section 327 of the SECURE 2.0 Act, an election available for calendar years beginning after December 31, 2023. That election uses the Uniform Lifetime Table, which produces smaller required amounts than the Single Life Table.
• Take the death benefit in cash anyway, if income now matters more than deferral later. Continuation is an option, never an obligation.

What happens if the beneficiary is not a spouse?

A non-spouse beneficiary gets a deadline, and which deadline depends entirely on what kind of money funded the annuity. This is the single most misunderstood point in the whole topic, because the famous 10-year rule does not apply to every inherited annuity.

The upshot for most non-spouse beneficiaries is that they are choosing between speed and smoothness, not between paying tax and not paying tax. The full mechanics live in our guide to the 10-year rule for inherited annuities.

Who counts as an eligible designated beneficiary?

An eligible designated beneficiary is a non-spouse who Congress decided should keep the old stretch treatment, and there are five categories. If you fall into one, you generally take payments over your life expectancy instead of racing a 10-year clock.

• A surviving spouse. Always at the top of the list, with the continuation and rollover rights above.
• A minor child of the account owner. The life expectancy payout runs until the child reaches age 21, and then a 10-year clock begins. A grandchild does not qualify, and neither does a stepchild who was not the owner’s child.
• A disabled beneficiary. Disability is defined by IRC section 72(m)(7), a stricter standard than most people expect.
• A chronically ill beneficiary. Defined by IRC section 7702B(c)(2), the same definition used in long-term care insurance.
• Anyone not more than 10 years younger than the owner. This is the category that quietly covers siblings, partners, and close friends of a similar age.

Everyone outside those five categories is simply a designated beneficiary and lives with the 10-year rule. And a beneficiary who is not a person at all, such as an estate or most trusts, gets the harshest treatment: a 5-year deadline when the owner died before their required beginning date, or payments over the owner’s own remaining life expectancy when the owner died after it.

Spouse vs non-spouse inherited annuity at a glance

Here is the whole fork on one screen. Read down your column, not across the page.

Does the SECURE Act 10-year rule cover every inherited annuity?

No, and this is where most online explanations go wrong. The SECURE Act of 2019 rewrote the rules for inherited retirement accounts, which includes annuities held inside an IRA or an employer plan. It did not rewrite IRC section 72(s), which governs non-qualified annuities bought with after-tax money.

Insurers administer these two rule sets differently, and the claim form you receive will usually list only the options that apply to your contract. If the form offers a 5-year option and no 10-year option, that is your clue you are holding a non-qualified contract.

How is an inherited annuity taxed either way?

Gains are taxed as ordinary income to whoever receives them, and there is no capital-gains rate and no step-up in basis to soften it. What changes between spouse and non-spouse is the timing, not the character of the tax.

One piece of good news for every beneficiary: the 10 percent early distribution penalty generally does not apply to money received because of the owner’s death, under IRC 72(q)(2)(B) for non-qualified annuities and IRC 72(t)(2)(A)(ii) for retirement accounts. A 30-year-old who inherits still owes income tax, but not the penalty. Our overview of how annuities are taxed walks through the calculations, and annuity death benefit taxation covers what heirs see on the 1099-R.

This article is general education, not tax advice. Inherited annuity taxation turns on facts specific to the contract and the beneficiary, so confirm your situation with a qualified tax professional before you file any election.

What are the honest downsides of spousal continuation?

Continuing the contract is not automatically the right move, and a surviving spouse who elects it out of habit can lock themselves into terms they would not choose today.

• The surrender schedule may keep running. Some carriers restart or continue the surrender charge period on continuation, which limits access to the money for years.
• The crediting rate may be stale. A contract bought years ago may pay less than what the same carrier offers on a new contract today, and continuation keeps you in the old one.
• The tax bill does not disappear, it moves. Deferral means a larger balance later, taxed at whatever the surviving spouse’s bracket is then, often as a single filer rather than a joint one.
• Rider benefits can change or end. Death benefit riders and income riders sometimes do not survive a change of owner. Ask before you elect.
• A spouse under 59 and a half who rolls an IRA annuity into their own name can lose the death-distribution penalty exception on later withdrawals.

None of these makes continuation wrong. They make it a decision worth an hour of real analysis rather than a box checked on a claim form.

What should a beneficiary do in the first 90 days?

Do nothing irreversible until you know which set of rules applies to you, then take the first required step on time. Most costly mistakes in this area come from moving too fast, not too slowly.

Moving forward

Come back to the deed and the guest pass. If you are a surviving spouse and the sole beneficiary, you were handed the deed: you can keep the contract, keep the deferral, and decide on your own timetable. If you are anyone else, you were handed a guest pass with a checkout time, and your real job is choosing how to walk out the door in the way that costs you the least in tax.

Neither answer is obvious from the claim form. The form lists options; it does not tell you which one fits a 57-year-old in a high bracket versus a 68-year-old who just retired. That comparison is the work, and it is worth doing before the paperwork is signed rather than after. AnnuaLife’s Certified Annuity Advisor match exists for exactly this kind of question, and the inherited annuity guide is a good next read while you gather the contract facts.

Frequently asked questions